Dave Burke : Freelance .NET Web Developer specializing in Online Communities

Registration Requirement to Comment at DBVT.COM is Dead

I know it’s been a long time coming and I apologize to everyone who bumped up against a “Please login” link when wanting to add a comment at DBVT.COM, but I am happy to announce that the requirement to create a site account to comment on my blog is now dead.  After spending quality time with BlogEngine.NET’s Spam Filtering in v1.6 I know I can fully trust it to manage spam effectively for me. I can’t imagine that another blog application can do a better job preventing spam, and it’s only due to my lack of experience with v1.6’s spam module that kept the registration requirement in place.  I am wiser now.

Since I had been leveraging the Sueetie Framework with a CurrentSueetieUser.IsRegistered test, I thought why not add the option for Sueetie Blog Administrators to determine whether they want a Registered User Requirement for blog comments. Requiring membership to post blog comments at Sueetie.com makes sense and is still in place, for instance.  It doesn’t make sense at dbvt.com.

You can see the updated Sueetie Blog Administrative form below with the “Require User Registration to Comment” setting.

If you're interested in the logic of displaying the login prompt, the excerpt from the BlogEngine.NET CommentView control is shown below. What’s interesting is how Sueetie has the intelligence to know its current context and application, so we use the ApplicationKey property of the SueetieApplications.Current application to retrieve the current SueetieBlog object and it’s RegisteredComments property.

Comments (5) | Post RSS RSS comment feed

Posted on 5/21/2010 6:20:39 PM by Dave Burke
Categories: Sueetie
Tags: |

Related posts

Comments (5) -

5/23/2010 7:46:54 AM Permalink

I have error in 4 line code in this code which has been showed. Frown help

Karcher wroclaw United States |

5/24/2010 7:21:59 AM Permalink

Karcher,

This only works with the Sueetie Framework in Gummy Bear v1.3 coming in June.

-Dave

daveburke United States |

5/31/2010 2:45:28 PM Permalink

Heya Dave,

Glad to see that you were able to get it to work.  When I added Invisible CAPTCHA to comments on my site (thanks to the links in a post of yours), it made everyone very happy as I finally was able to allow anonymous comments.  A little over a year ago spammers created ways to automatically create user accounts on CS systems, so I had to add CAPTCHA to account creation, which completely ended the spam accounts.

I don't know if you have the SPAM account problem, but what they do is create thousands of accounts with ads in the profiles, which show up in search engines and basically hijack your site w/o you even knowing about it.  You might want to see if you're having that problem as well.

Take it easy,
Bill

Bill Bosacker United States |

5/31/2010 2:51:04 PM Permalink

Bill,

Thanks.  Yes, like your users, I'm very happy to enable anonymous comments again.

The last active CS site of mine was http://driveframework.com, which is still online, but I got hit with so much registration spam that I finally closed down registration altogether.  Geez.

Good to hear from you.

-Dave

daveburke United States |

6/5/2010 10:46:57 AM Permalink

The code is working for me. Thanks

jenny United States |


Powered by BlogEngine.NET 2.0.0.36
Theme by Dave Burke